About that ‘Humanae vitae’ rumor

One comment

Contraception and magisterial authority.

In the Light of the Law

Too many Roman rumors, it seems of late, have turned out to be true (or close enough to true) to rule out recent rumors that a “papal commission” has been set up “to reconsider” (perhaps as a step toward repudiating?) Bl. Pope Paul VI’s encyclical Humanae vitae (1968). In any event, a few observations.

1. Humanae vitae itself, as brilliant as it was and as prophetic as it turned out to be, was not an infallible exercise of the (papal) magisterium. But rather than defend that view against the few serious-thinking Catholics who might disagree let me move directly to my second point.

2. In my opinion the central teaching in Humanae vitae—that contraception between married couples (both terms being correctly understood) is intrinsically evil—is a proposition infallibly taught by the (ordinary universal) magisterium of the Church. I say this in light of my third point.


View original post 402 more words

1 comments on “About that ‘Humanae vitae’ rumor”

  1. On Fri, Jul 14, 2017 at 4:59 AM HOPE IN THE STORM wrote:

    > Jay Toups posted: “Contraception and magisterial authority. ” >


Comments are closed.